Don’t Say THIS to Your Plumber, Kevin

Don’t Say THIS to Your Plumber, Kevin. It might sound harmless at first, but there are certain comments, questions, or assumptions that can put tension on the relationship between a plumber and a customer in an instant. Whether you’re a homeowner, property manager, or someone just curious about how plumbing services work, you’ll benefit from understanding why certain phrases can frustrate your plumber—and possibly cost you more time and money in the long run.

Below, we’ll explore nine statements you should avoid saying to a plumber. You’ll learn what makes each statement problematic, why it might lead to misunderstandings or surprise fees, and how to approach your plumbing needs in a more productive way. By the end of this post, you’ll be armed with insights that can help you build a better rapport with your plumber, save money, and ensure your home’s plumbing is fixed properly, the first time.

Statement #1: “This should only take five minutes.”

When you tell a plumber something should only take a few minutes, you’re inadvertently undermining the experience and skill they’ve built over the years. The statement suggests that because it seems simple on the surface, it must be quick and easy for them to complete. Yet plumbing problems can be far more complex than they appear.

• Why It’s Problematic:

  1. Underestimating Expertise: Plumbers invest significant time and money to learn their trade, acquire licenses, and gain hands-on experience. Even tasks that look simple—such as changing a cartridge or reseating a fixture—may require specialized tools or a structured approach.

  2. Unrealistic Time Expectations: You might imagine it’s a five-minute task, but you don’t account for the plumber’s travel time, the initial inspection, potential complications, or cleanup.

• A Better Approach: Instead of insisting a repair will be quick, ask politely how long it might take. This shows you respect their process and want to understand the timeline without minimizing their effort.

Statement #2: “I already bought the parts on Amazon.”

It’s easy to understand why you might purchase your own parts: online marketplaces often have lower prices or promise quick shipping. However, when you hand a plumber a box of parts you found on the internet, you could be inviting unforeseen issues.

• Why It’s Problematic:

  1. Quality Concerns: Parts sold online at steep discounts can be inferior in quality, built with cheaper materials, or not made to precise specifications. If a part isn’t quite the right size or shape, it can lead to leaks—or a complete failure of the fixture.

  2. Warranty Complications: When a plumber supplies parts, they can typically guarantee both the product and the labor. If something goes wrong with parts the plumber didn’t provide, you may have no warranty protection from the plumber’s side.

  3. Return Headaches: If the part you bought on Amazon doesn’t fit or malfunctions, you have to deal with returning or exchanging it. Meanwhile, the plumber’s time is still running.

• A Better Approach: Trust your plumber’s recommended parts unless you have a compelling reason not to. Ask if they provide a warranty and if they stand by the quality of their supplies. In most cases, the cost of quality parts is worth avoiding the hassle of rework or future leaks.

Statement #3: “Can you give me the price over the phone?”

Everyone wants an estimate before committing to a service. However, plumbing isn’t one-size-fits-all. A simple job in one home might become a major undertaking in another, all due to differences like pipe location, fixture types, hidden damage, or the building’s layout.

• Why It’s Problematic:

  1. Lack of Inspection: Without seeing the problem firsthand, a plumber can’t accurately diagnose the issue. That means any phone quote is little more than a guess, potentially leaving you upset if the final invoice is higher.

  2. Unique Circumstances: A water heater in a ground-level garage is often more accessible than one tucked behind holiday decorations in a cramped attic. Physical challenges drastically affect labor time and cost.

• A Better Approach: Accept that a nominal trip or inspection fee is part of getting an accurate quote. View it like a consultation: you’re paying for a professional’s eyes on the problem, ensuring the final price reflects your actual situation, not a phone-based assumption.

Statement #4: “Another plumber said they’d do it for less.”

In plumbing, you often get what you pay for. If you mention a cheaper quote from someone else, your plumber may assume you’re trying to haggle or guilt them into lowering their rates. While you have the right to compare prices, doing so in a confrontational way can strain the relationship.

• Why It’s Problematic:

  1. Demeans Expertise: Plumbers who value their craft often price their services to reflect experience, training, insurance, and overhead. Implying they’re overpriced can come across as an insult.

  2. Quality vs. Cost: Lower quotes might mean someone cutting corners, using cheaper parts, or lacking proper licensing. If that cheaper plumber doesn’t do a thorough job, you could end up paying more in the long run.

• A Better Approach: If you’re shopping around, do so before hiring someone. Once you’ve found a plumber you trust, avoid pitting them against others purely on price. Ask about their certifications, warranties, and customer service track record to see if their higher rate might actually offer better value.

Statement #5: “Can I stand here and watch?”

Wanting to see what a plumber is doing isn’t necessarily a problem, especially if you’re genuinely interested in how things work. However, hovering can slow the plumber down and add pressure, especially if you’re questioning each step.

• Why It’s Problematic:

  1. Distraction Factor: Constantly explaining every move takes the plumber away from their flow. Simple tasks can take much longer when interrupted with questions.

  2. Safety & Liability: If you’re in the way of tools, heavy pipes, or scorching water lines, there’s a real risk of injury.

• A Better Approach: Let the plumber work. If you have questions, wait until there’s a natural break—like when they’re testing something or finishing up. Many plumbers are happy to explain what they’ve done, but they also need space to do their job safely and efficiently.

Statement #6: “I already tried fixing it myself.”

DIY spirit can be admirable, but if you’re calling a plumber after you’ve tinkered with the pipes, you probably ran into an unexpected obstacle. Telling a plumber you “already tried fixing it” might imply you suspect they’re about to charge you just to redo your work, or that you might have worsened the situation.

• Why It’s Problematic:

  1. Hidden Damage: If your fix involved the wrong tool or technique, you could have created more leaks, stripped threads, or damaged washers and seals. The plumber now has extra work to uncover or repair your initial attempt.

  2. Misplaced Responsibility: Sometimes, a homeowner’s partial fix can mask deeper issues. When the plumber arrives, it may look temporarily okay—until everything suddenly fails. The plumber might feel they’re being held responsible for something the homeowner caused.

• A Better Approach: Briefly mention any attempt you made, but don’t frame it as “it should be close to done.” Instead, explain what you observed, any steps you tried, and what seemed to happen afterward. This context helps the plumber diagnose the true cause more quickly.

Statement #7: “Can I get a discount?”

Everyone appreciates a bargain, but expecting a discount just because you asked can be off-putting. Most plumbing companies set their prices based on careful calculations of parts, labor, overhead, and warranties.

• Why It’s Problematic:

  1. Undervalues Labor & Overhead: It costs money to run a legitimate plumbing business—fuel, insurance, equipment, training, and staff benefits. Slashing prices may mean staff wages or service quality suffer.

  2. Creates a Transactional Atmosphere: Negotiating is sometimes reasonable, but if the plumber senses you believe they’re overpriced, the relationship becomes adversarial rather than collaborative.

• A Better Approach: Instead of asking for a discount outright, inquire about service bundles or preventive maintenance plans that might reduce costs in the long term. Some plumbers offer loyalty programs or seasonal promotions you can take advantage of without haggling on the spot.

Statement #8: “Why do I have to pay a service fee?”

Service or trip fees can seem frustrating when you only need a small repair. However, keep in mind the plumber’s investment in people, equipment, and time.

• Why It’s Problematic:

  1. Neglects Operational Costs: When a plumber arrives at your doorstep, they bring years of training, a specialized vehicle, tools, and the necessary parts to handle most common repairs. Maintaining a “warehouse on wheels” isn’t free.

  2. Pays for Diagnosis: Even if the fix itself is quick, diagnosing the root of a problem can be challenging. The service fee covers the plumber’s expertise in identifying the correct repair.

• A Better Approach: Ask what’s included in the service fee. Many plumbers will explain that the fee ensures a professional arrives with the right tools and knowledge. Accepting it as part of a fair business model encourages a respectful relationship, ensuring they’re properly compensated for their time and resources.

Statement #9: “If this is so quick, why is it so expensive?”

When the actual repair takes only minutes, it might seem unfair that the cost is still relatively high. However, the skill and efficiency of a trained professional often lets them do in minutes what a novice might struggle with for hours.

• Why It’s Problematic:

  1. Confuses Labor with Expertise: You aren’t paying only for the time physically spent working. You’re paying for the plumber’s ability to diagnose the problem, choose the correct solution, and perform the fix efficiently.

  2. Ignores Hidden Costs: The final price factors in travel, overhead, inventory, and potential hidden issues that require readiness. An accurate quote has to account for unexpected complications as well.

• A Better Approach: Recognize that you’re paying for years of training, specialized tools, and the reliability of a professional fix. If you have concerns about pricing, it’s better to bring them up before the work begins, so you and the plumber can discuss options or potential add-ons you might face.

Conclusion

The relationship between a customer and a plumber works best when built on mutual respect and clear communication. Questions like “Why does it cost so much if it’s so quick?” or comments about parts purchased online can strain that relationship if not handled with an open mind. Ultimately, plumbers are professionals who invest in their licenses, keep up with industry standards, and come prepared to tackle a wide variety of issues hidden behind walls and under floors.

By avoiding these nine statements, you’ll stand out as a well-informed and courteous customer. That often translates into better service, more straightforward interactions, and a plumber who’s motivated to do the job right and on time. Next time you need a plumbing repair, focus on collaborative communication. Ask for explanations or clarifications if you’re curious, but remember that you’re hiring an expert for their specialized knowledge and experience.

When you treat your plumber with the same consideration you’d expect if someone hired you, you create a positive working environment for everyone. After all, keeping your home’s water flowing smoothly and your drains functioning properly is a job worth respecting.